Wanted: A High-Growth Energy Storage Stock

In a world of gene modifying and AI-powered brain-computer interfaces, vitality storage hasn’t modified a lot. Positive, advances have been made in density, resulting in the miniaturization of lithium batteries, which has popularized drones and electrical autos. The expansion of renewable vitality has additionally led to an elevated demand for vitality storage options. The icing on the cake? President Biden’s Inflation Discount Act guarantees to channel funding and tax credit to builders of inexperienced vitality options. This has led to a robust curiosity from retail buyers eager to search out publicity to battery shares and vitality storage options.

Whereas a lot of the consideration will get paid to lithium batteries, that’s only one element of the vitality storage thesis which we’ve divided into the next classes:

• Lithium battery producers
• Vitality storage options suppliers
• New battery know-how builders

Our tech inventory catalog accommodates 16 firms which fall into the above classes which we’ll study right now in our seek for a horny high-growth vitality storage play for our personal tech inventory portfolio. We’ll begin by firms that manufacture batteries – the picks and shovels of vitality storage.

Lithium Battery Producers

Our article on The 8 Largest Lithium Battery Shares of 2028 vetted the most important (projected) producers of lithium batteries and located a number of names that will advantage additional examination comparable to BYD and CATL (each Chinese language companies). Whereas we don’t put money into VIE constructions, BYD truly trades as an H share which implies that threat is eradicated. Although some geopolitical dangers stay, we’re due for an replace on BYD since our final piece in 2017. As for CATL, they’ve been hinting at an IPO in Hong Kong, however they’re off our radar till they commerce as an H share.

With a market cap of $100 billion, BYD additionally manufactures electrical autos, which implies they’re not a pure play. Ideally, we’re searching for a pure play to put money into. The identical is true for Tesla, a $576 billion electrical car behemoth that properly exceeds our optimum dimension goal of $10 billion to $100 billion.

There are some midcap battery producers to contemplate, one being EnerSys (ENS), an organization we uncovered in our piece on 3 Mid-Cap International Battery Producer Shares. (Extra on this firm in a bit.) In that very same article, we checked out Taiwans’ Simplo (6121.TWO), a agency that’s too troublesome to comply with in your common retail investor who doesn’t learn Mandarin. The third firm, Germany’s VARTA (VAR1.DE), has too heavy a reliance on Apple for wi-fi headphone batteries. These chickens apparently got here house to roost as that section not too long ago noticed a 25% drop in revenues:

The present difficult financial state of affairs and restrained shopper demand are compromising demand for lithium-ion batteries for True Wi-fi Stereo Headsets (TWS) within the space of Lithium-Ion CoinPower.

Credit score: Varta

Newcomers to the scene embrace Microvast (MVST), an organization we lined earlier this yr in a chunk titled Microvast Inventory is a Pure Play on EV Battery Know-how. Positive, they’re promoting plenty of batteries and tools, however they’re having a tough time making a worthwhile enterprise out of it. Gross margins for Microvast have barely been within the inexperienced during the last 4 quarters.

We famous a heavy dependency on China the place practically all their operations are situated. It’s a geopolitical threat that may’t be ignored as relations bitter between two of the world’s most economically highly effective nations. Bulls will level to the current $200 million grant Microvast obtained in partnership with Normal Motors, and certainly that sounds good on the tin. Maybe one might look previous the China dependencies, however what’s unimaginable to get previous are these dreadfully low gross margins.

The final time we checked out Enovix (ENVX) was again in July 2020 shortly after they raised $45 million to finish their totally automated industrial manufacturing line by year-end. Issues are off to a gradual begin. Right here’s a remark from the newest shareholder letter:

We’re persevering with to push the boundaries of what’s attainable with our know-how whereas creating a world class manufacturing line to gas our development and fulfill our prospects

Credit score: Enovix

Most buyers can be joyful to commerce some boundary pushing for some battery gross sales. This $1.9 billion firm’s shiny SPAC deck mentioned we must always anticipate to see revenues of $11 million for 2022 and $176 million for 2023. In the event that they hit that 2022 aim, we’ll come again for a re-evaluation.

Vitality Storage Options

Notable names to look at on this area are Stem (STEM) and Fluence (FLNC), each of which we’re avoiding in the mean time.

• Fluence Vitality – COGS is larger than revenues which means they don’t have a viable enterprise. Siemens – a associated celebration – accounts for greater than half of their revenues. Practically all revenues come from promoting {hardware}. We would take one other have a look at the corporate as soon as they will present recurring revenues that represent a significant share of whole revenues.
• Stem Inc. – Round 96% of income comes from the US and practically half of 2022 revenues to this point have come from one buyer. Practically 80% comes from reselling {hardware} from producers like Tesla, Sungrow, and Powin Vitality. ARR is rising slowly (5% sequentially final quarter) and total gross margins have been an unimpressive 9%.

Each these enterprise fashions sound good on paper – promote vitality storage options, then generate recurring revenues over time – however the actuality up to now isn’t compelling.

New Battery Applied sciences

The emergence of special purpose acquisition companies (SPACs) offered a pathway for firms to go public on the peak of inflated expectations. Many promising battery know-how firms at the moment are publicly traded firms and not using a drop of income. Under are some names we’re avoiding together with hyperlinks to articles discussing their applied sciences.

The above names have been all prone to hype and noticed share costs soar earlier than correcting together with the broader market. Main the pack is QuantumScape, a developer of solid-state lithium metallic batteries for electrical vehicles that’s in mattress with Volkswagen. Since its peak of $114 a share, QS shares have fallen -94% as everybody waits for manufacturing to start in 2024. Following one easy rule would have protected buyers from such dramatic fallout – by no means put money into firms except they’ve significant revenues. Irrespective of how low these shares sink, there’s no worth to be discovered except traction has been confirmed. Elevating capital is tougher in bear markets so there’s additionally a threat of chapter that must be thought of now.

Maybe the brightest star of the bunch is one other solid-state battery producer named Strong Energy which has handily beat their 2022 income estimates of $3 million with year-to-date revenues totaling $7.6 million. Whereas the present market cap is properly beneath our $1 billion threshold, we’ll doubtless revisit the agency someday subsequent yr offered they exceed $10 million in 2022 revenues. As for FREYR (SemiSolid lithium-ion know-how from 24M) and SES (AI, supplies, and extra), we’re not going to take a second have a look at both firm till they notice greater than $10 million in annual revenues.

EOS claims to have constructed the primary commercially accessible battery that doesn’t have a lithium-ion chemistry. For an organization that started transport techniques in 2018, they haven’t made a lot progress having most not too long ago introduced in $6.1 million in revenues for Q3-2022 with a cost of goods sprevious (COGS) totaling $50 million. That’s not an economically viable enterprise, particularly when you think about this $83 million firm has simply $38 million in money remaining and a share value that’s flirting with delisting.

Vitality Vault has probably the most distinctive know-how which entails hoisting blocks of concrete into the air and releasing them to create energy, the tip end result being a primitive type of vitality storage that competes with the world’s hottest – pumped storage hydro crops. Revenues have began coming in, a decent $45 million up to now this yr. Drawback is, 97% of that got here from one in every of their buyers as a part of a $50 million licensing payment (looks like this ought to be said as related-party revenues). We might come again round for an additional look if revenues begin to develop exterior of their preparations with investor Atlas Renewable which is basically owned by a Chinese language vitality agency with plans to develop the venture in China.

Our Battery Publicity

Pontificating concerning the deserves of recent battery applied sciences is futile. We’ve learn a whole bunch of articles speaking about nano-enabled cathodes, graphene supplies, circulate batteries, solid-state lithium batteries, and the listing goes on. Many of those companies are non-public, and extra examples might be present in our piece on How Lithium-Ion Batteries Will Proceed to Enhance. Too many battery know-how firms have gone bankrupt through the years for us to waste time digging into the story du jour. When a battery tech firm has significant revenues and seems to be on the cusp of an actual development trajectory, we’ll examine. This rule applies to most of the shares we’ve checked out right now.

When setting up our tech-stock portfolio, we’ve sometimes chosen to incorporate “placeholders” that are supposed to present publicity to a chance that may not but present itself in enough type. EnerSys represents such a place, and it’s beginning to be a deja vu of the current piece we did on NextEra Vitality: Development Inventory or Worth Inventory? Whereas revenues could also be rising over time giving the looks of a development inventory, it’s truly a worth inventory underneath the hood. Paying a dividend and never giving buyers any steering on revenues (solely earnings-per-share) is attribute of a worth inventory, not a development inventory.

Holding EnerSys whereas we wait doesn’t seem to be the worst concept. Administration anticipates they’ll profit from the Inflation Discount Act, whereas the most recent investor deck dedicates a significant quantity of actual property speaking about how they’ll be capable of react positively to a attainable recession. We’ve carried out our yearly checkup and can proceed to carry shares till we discover a higher substitute. What’s that you simply say? You recognize of 1? Carry on studying then.

Different Vitality Storage Shares

No vitality storage article can be full with out mentioning the hydrogen economic system thesis. Whereas we’ve written extensively concerning the matter through the years, we’re at present engaged on a analysis piece that appears at hydrogen from a 20,000-foot view. The thought will not be as inexperienced or as economically viable as we’re being led to consider. Keep tuned.

One other concept getting plenty of consideration from buyers is battery recycling. Li-cycle (LICY) dabbles in lithium battery recycling, a website that’s more likely to obtain advantages from the Inflation Discount Act. The newest Q3-2022 revenues included an advanced downwards adjustment which displays a robust dependency on commodity costs. We’ll in all probability watch for the 2022 mud to settle and see how they’re progressing someday subsequent yr.

This text largely surrounds the 16 vitality storage/battery shares present in our tech inventory catalog. Consequently, this piece will appeal to feedback round firms we “missed” which is nice. Please be happy to recommend companies we ought to have a look at with a number of caveats. No pre-revenue firms, no over-the-counter firms, and no shares with a market cap of lower than $750 million (our market cap cutoff is $1 billion, however we’ll enable for some leeway). Ultimately, we’ll discover a great way to play the expansion of vitality storage. Till then, we’ll maintain our placeholder – EnerSys – and carry on researching.

Conclusion

A few of our hottest vitality storage content material has been round options suppliers comparable to Stem and Fluence. Battery applied sciences at all times draw a crowd as properly. Whereas the bull thesis for vitality storage is clear, particularly in mild of the Inflation Discount Act, what’s missing is a compelling inventory that represents a pure-play technique to play the vitality storage theme. EnerSys is a placeholder we don’t plan on including to, nor will we plan on promoting the inventory till we discover a appropriate technique to play the vitality storage thesis.

Tech investing is extraordinarily dangerous. Decrease your threat with our inventory analysis, funding instruments, and portfolios, and discover out which tech shares you need to keep away from. Turn out to be a Nanalyze Premium member and discover out right now!