Which phone-powered PC experience is better?

I’ve been having fun with Google’s new Pixel Desktop Mode on my Pixel 10 Professional XL currently, a lot in order that it virtually makes the world of smartphones really feel new once more. Nevertheless, Google is way from the primary to mix smartphone and desktop experiences beneath one roof. US shoppers have had entry to Samsung’s DeX surroundings since 2017, and it has progressively improved the platform with numerous new options which have set a excessive bar for Google’s new system to fulfill.

If something, it’s stunning that it’s taken Google simply this lengthy to provide you with its personal tackle the components. However how do they examine? I’ve spent a while attempting out on a regular basis desktop duties on each platforms to assist reply the query: What are the variations between Pixel Desktop and Samsung DeX, and which one is finest?

Earlier than moving into the options, there’s one core distinction between these two desktop platforms. Pixel Desktop Mode runs the very same Android system that powers the cellphone interface, merely rendering a second windowing surroundings on the exterior show. Apps run in the identical OS occasion, however Android’s native window supervisor permits them to seem in resizable home windows on the bigger display.

Samsung DeX takes a special method. Reasonably than counting on Android’s new default desktop-style windowing, Samsung layers its personal desktop interface on high of Android by means of One UI. Apps nonetheless run in the identical Android OS occasion, however Samsung replaces a lot of the system’s window administration and UI conduct with its personal desktop shell. This barely totally different structure leads to a couple refined variations within the expertise, which we’ll get into in a minute, however the finish outcome remains to be a local Android desktop expertise.

Fortunately, getting began with both desktop choice is equally easy. Each platforms assist DisplayPort output by way of USB-C, and you may simply join up by way of HDMI by means of a dongle adapter. Nevertheless, older Samsung fashions had a couple of different methods to attach, equivalent to a DeX cable or Wi-fi DeX, which the Pixel doesn’t have.

The telephones I used assist energy pass-through and hassle-free plug-and-play assist for Bluetooth and USB keyboard and mice. For sure, I had no downside getting began with both, and each serve precisely the identical objective at a fast look.

Sticking with peripherals for a second, each desktop environments assist the identical Bluetooth peripherals as in cell mode, so you may preserve your earbuds paired when switching between modes. I additionally plugged in a microSD card, a USB stick, and a USB SSD exterior storage machine, all of which have been detected immediately with out challenge, permitting you to port work round very simply.

Likewise, when booting into Samsung DeX or Pixel Desktop Mode, you’re greeted with a really acquainted desktop look on each platforms. The 2 interfaces place a customizable dock of apps alongside the underside, full with an app drawer, and Android’s traditional three navigation buttons. The one distinction is that DeX positions these on the left and Pixel on the fitting. The 2 platforms additionally assist as much as 4 separate desktop environments as properly, so you may preserve even the busiest multi-tasking setups so as.

Maybe crucial issue is how the 2 desktop modes deal with operating your normal array of Android apps, and once more, the expertise may be very related. Google has pushed builders to assist a wider vary of side ratios in recent times, out of your normal cellphone portrait to wider foldable and pill UIs. Pixel Desktop Mode leverages these choices, mechanically refreshing the UI to suit essentially the most relevant mode whenever you resize your window. DeX works in a really related means, permitting you to resize home windows to no matter dimension and adapting the UI the place potential.

Nevertheless, not each app has been up to date to assist the broader vary of UI choices out there in immediately’s Android ecosystem. Within the outdated days, DeX used to place older apps into fastened home windows, however I couldn’t discover any apps that defaulted to this mode; all of the apps I attempted could possibly be stretched and expanded. The truth is, DeX dealt with some older apps higher than the Pixel, which defaulted to full display and have become unresponsive with a few older apps I attempted that undoubtedly weren’t constructed for widescreen assist. That’s a minor distinction within the grand scheme, although.

On the entire, each DeX and Pixel desktop modes present very related core performance and run immediately’s fashionable Android apps simply as properly in desktop mode as in cellphone mode.

Eagle-eyed readers may have already noticed a couple of key variations after we first regarded on the interfaces. DeX defaults to exhibiting a couple of desktop icons, together with the dock, and you may add apps to the desktop grid just by clicking and dragging them out of the app drawer. The truth is, DeX’s desktop is a completely customizable panorama all of its personal, full with the exact same widgets you may plaster throughout your cellphone’s homescreen. Importantly, adjustments made right here don’t have an effect on your cellphone’s homescreen. In the meantime, Pixel’s desktop is basically only a glorified wallpaper. In contrast to DeX​, you may’t place app icons or widgets straight on it.

One other important change is the way in which the 2 deal with fast settings and notifications. DeX provides these choices as extra acquainted “system tray” or “notification space” gadgets, together with a calendar and clock. Clicking any of those icons opens the related settings, permitting fast entry to verify your schedule, toggle Bluetooth connections, or reply to an incoming message. It’s very PC-like. Google at present has nothing like this.

As a substitute, Pixel opts for a top-down, phone-inspired method to notifications and fast settings. Whereas that is acquainted in a single sense, it’s at odds with muscle reminiscence for the way we anticipate desktop interfaces to work. For a begin, the tiny little clock or connectivity icons you must click on on the high of the display are far too small. Even after you lastly pull down the menu, it nonetheless takes up the whole display, blocking your apps and limiting your multitasking. In comparison with a pleasant little pop-up in conjunction with your display, it’s not nice.

It’s not a clear sweep for DeX, although. On my Samsung Galaxy S25 Extremely, DeX scaled Chrome so aggressively that navigating some pages grew to become awkward. It’s primarily trapped within the cell world, inflicting all types of formatting points when viewing pages on a big display. Requesting desktop variations of web sites helped, however not sufficiently to make this a local expertise — you’re finest off sticking to Samsung Web, which works flawlessly. By comparability, Google has gone to some effort to make sure a extra desktop-like Chrome expertise, although it nonetheless lacks extensions.

By now, you may in all probability inform I’m leaning extra in favor of DeX than Pixel Desktop Mode, however just for a couple of small quality-of-life enhancements quite than a core performance distinction.

As an example, DeX does a greater job of surfacing further however essential Exterior Show settings. There’s a devoted choice for display timeout for PC mode, which is frustratingly the identical for cellphone and desktop modes on the Pixel. Moreover, you may set PC-only wallpapers on DeX whereas all customization settings are shared on Google’s implementation. My Galaxy S25 Extremely even includes a good little touchpad button on the backside left of the cellphone display, letting me simply navigate the exterior show with no mouse related. Factors for DeX right here; the platform’s maturity and further years beneath refinement do make it that little bit nicer to make use of.

I can finest sum up the distinction because the Pixel’s setup is extra restricted in a single key means: its UI remains to be very a lot sure to its cellphone interface. The phone-like notification panel and the shortage of per-interface persistent settings are minor gripes, however they’re actually sufficient to take the shine off the expertise for energy customers. When you peel again the wrapper, it’s clear that you just’re nonetheless very a lot engaged on a Pixel cellphone, whereas DeX has a clearer separation between its cellphone host and the desktop interface you wish to spend time doing severe work in. It’s solely small variations, however they add up.

Pixel Desktop Mode reveals the place Android is heading — a single OS that scales seamlessly from cellphone to desktop. Google plans to tackle desktops with Aluminium OS earlier than the tip of the 12 months, in any case. However immediately, Samsung DeX nonetheless feels just like the extra full desktop surroundings due to its further refinement. The hole isn’t large, although, and if Google continues iterating at its present tempo, Pixel Desktop Mode might not keep behind for lengthy.