Is It Time to Worry About the Slowdown in DocuSign Stock?

There are some things it’s best to do annually. Go to your physician. Swim within the ocean. Climb a mountain. And test in your long-term inventory investments. The present lull following the IPO gold rush over the past couple of years has given our MBAs some a lot wanted time to refine their blunt-rolling expertise consider our present holdings. For instance, we informed you why we’re not nervous in regards to the huge plummet in C3.ai inventory, in addition to confirmed our confidence within the main robotic course of automation inventory and a digital funds inventory that’s competing towards one of many greatest names in fintech. The subsequent checkup is with DocuSign (DOCU), a legaltech inventory that till just lately had been rising revenues like loopy.

However the newest quarterly outcomes from the corporate present that income progress is slowing whereas losses proceed to pile up. Is it time to fret in regards to the slowdown in DocuSign inventory?

Doing a Double Tackle DocuSign Inventory

In our Might 2021 article on DocuSign, we discovered loads to like in regards to the firm, which has developed a cloud-based platform known as DocuSign Settlement Cloud that automates the paperwork course of for agreements, contracts, and even digital pinky swears (OK, we made that final one up). For one factor, practically all of its income comes from software-as-a–service (SaaS) subscriptions. SaaS is a lovely enterprise mannequin as a result of it often comes with excessive gross margins, which merely signifies that it doesn’t price some huge cash to become profitable. Within the case of DocuSign, the corporate persistently clocks in with a gross margin of about 78%, which is within the prime 10 of the 23 pure-SaaS firms present in our tech inventory catalog.

This has grow to be an vital metric as tech firm valuations plummet and buyers demand at the very least some signal that profitability is coming. That brings us to Thursday’s earnings name with DocuSign administration. Complete income was $588.7 million, a rise of 25% year-over-year – however simply little greater than 1% in comparison with the earlier quarter of $580.8 million. Complete income steering for the present fiscal 12 months is between $2.47 billion and $2.48 billion, which hasn’t modified for the reason that firm issued its year-end fiscal assertion earlier this 12 months. 

What has modified is the anticipated progress in income. Final 12 months, the corporate recorded whole income of $2.1 billion, a rise of 45% year-over-year. On the excessive finish of projected revenues ($2.48 billion) for this fiscal 12 months, annualized progress would shrink to about 15% in comparison with final 12 months. That’s not stunning given the $185 million drop, or 6.8%, in billings steering. Since DocuSign payments clients prematurely of utilization after which prorates the income over the 12 months, the “billings” metric is a number one indicator for revenues.

Add in an enormous swing-and-miss on earnings and widening losses, and DocuSign noticed its inventory value drop greater than 20% on Friday. DocuSign inventory is down greater than 55% to this point this 12 months, about double what the main Nasdaq-tracking index fund, Invesco QQQ ETF (QQQ), has misplaced throughout that point. The silver lining is that DocuSign inventory is now moderately valued primarily based on our easy valuation ratio (present market cap/projected annual revenues) of about 5 (together with nearly each different tech inventory proper now). A 12 months in the past, the quantity was about 22, with something greater than 40 thought-about too richly valued.

How Shut is Adobe to DocuSign?

One key article of our religion has been the assumption that DocuSign is the market chief within the digital signature trade. It repeatedly claims a 70% share of a total addressable market (TAM) that it pegs at $25 billion. Making an attempt to confirm and examine that declare towards opponents has been difficult. As an example, a few totally different analysts declare DocuSign owns anyplace from about 45% to 80% of the e-signature market. It’s typically accepted that its predominant competitor is Adobe (ADBE), which has its personal cloud-based e-signature service known as Adobe Acrobat Signal that’s a part of the Adobe Doc Cloud suite. Final 12 months, that enterprise section had income of $1.97 billion, representing 32% year-over-year progress. 

In impact, DocuSign and Adobe Doc Cloud are equally sized companies primarily based on annual income – $2.1 billion versus $1.97 billion, respectively – although the latter represents solely about 12.5% of Adobe’s whole 2021 revenues of practically $15.8 billion. Sadly, neither firm breaks down their income by product, so it’s unattainable to quantify e-signature market share, particularly given the quite a few different firms providing this service. Whereas each platforms are mainly cloud-based companies for managing authorized paperwork, they provide and emphasize totally different capabilities.

A Chief in Contract Lifecycle Administration

Certainly, whereas DocuSign e-Signature and its varied add-ons are the purpose of entry for patrons, the corporate can also be focusing on one other $25 billion TAM in contract lifecycle management (CLM). CLM software program is just about what it seems like: Automating administration of a corporation’s contracts from starting to finish. DocuSign claims to make use of synthetic intelligence with two merchandise related to its CLM service:

• Perception makes use of AI to go looking and analyze agreements by authorized ideas and clauses. It will probably work throughout a big quantity of agreements, each from DocuSign eSignature and from different sources.
• Analyzer helps clients perceive what they’re signing earlier than they signal it. An add-on to Perception, Analyzer makes use of AI to investigate inbound agreements. It will probably detect the presence or absence of clauses by their sort, rating their danger, and extract key phrases.

DocuSign obtained into the CLM enterprise again in 2018 with the $220 million acquisition of Chicago-based SpringCM, adopted in 2020 by the $188 million acquisition of one other contracts software program firm known as Seal Software program. The latter acquisition is one in all a number of startups we beforehand coated that use AI to automate and analyze authorized contracts. Its capabilities are actually baked into the CLM answer within the DocuSign Settlement Cloud. The corporate apparently did job of integrating the applied sciences, as a result of it has topped Gartner’s Magic Quadrant for its CLM answer for the final couple of years:

Adobe additionally presents CLM options, however be aware that it’s not on Gartner’s radar. Nevertheless, you’ll discover there’s a firm among the many leaders that seems to be ranked near DocuSign. Let’s study a bit extra about this (nonetheless) privately owned competitor.

A CLM Unicorn and Competitor

Based in 2009, Seattle-based Icertis is one other AI legaltech startup that makes a speciality of CLM that we beforehand coated. The corporate has raised $371 million in disclosed funding from a couple of dozen buyers, together with outstanding names like enterprise capital agency Greycroft, the SoftBank Imaginative and prescient Fund, and SAP, an enterprise software program firm. Icertis was valued at about $5 billion earlier this 12 months following the SAP funding. The Icertis Contract Intelligence platform does all of it, from establishing a contract to authoring, approvals, negotiations, and all different facets of ongoing contract operations. It consists of purposes for particular companies, from medical trials to danger administration, as effectively AI-based purposes for issues like negotiations. And it even makes use of blockchain … someway.

Icertis claims to have managed greater than 10 million contracts value greater than $1 trillion in 40-plus languages throughout 90-plus international locations. Clients embrace Google, Microsoft, Daimler, Airbus, and Johnson & Johnson, amongst others. It is usually reportedly eyeing an IPO later this 12 months, which might give us some much-needed transparency into the numbers, together with the corporate’s declare to have revenues “far north” of $100 million. 

Retention and Growth By the Numbers

Revenues apart, DocuSign is dealing with sturdy competitors from SaaS firms like Adobe and Icertis. Paradoxically, the simpler these cloud-based doc firms make it for patrons to combine and function their platforms, the simpler it’s for these clients to decide on and even swap options primarily based on value or perks. That is the place {hardware} firms have one thing of a bonus due to the capital-intensive nature of some markets. For instance, Intuitive Surgical (ISRG) is way and away the market chief in robotic surgical procedure at 80%, whereas its opponents (together with huge medical gadget and healthcare firms like Medtronic and Johnson & Johnson) have largely struggled.  

However to our level: What’s DocuSign doing to retain and develop its market positions?

Retention is weakening a bit. On this week’s earnings name, DocuSign stated it achieved 114% greenback internet retention for the quarter, which is “inside its historic vary of 112% to 119%” however clearly on the decrease finish. It did add 67,000 new clients within the quarter, bringing its whole put in base to just about 1.24 million. In response to DocuSign, the 1.24 million set up base displays paying clients versus those that solely reap the benefits of the free however restricted DocuSign eSignature function.

The variety of paying clients spending greater than $300,000 on the platform grew 32% in comparison with a 12 months in the past to a complete of 886 clients. As well as, increasingly more of the corporate’s extra modest enlargement is coming from worldwide income, which now accounts for 25% of whole income. It outpaced home progress, with a 43% year-over-year improve to achieve $144 million within the first quarter. 

Newest Strikes to Bolster DocuSign Inventory

These are largely constructive numbers, however what’s the DocuSign management doing to strengthen the corporate’s long-term progress outlook?

Properly, the administration workforce is increasing its personal numbers with a bunch of recent hires, so we’re in all probability not going to see a drop in overhead there. One key rent is meant to bolster the corporate’s worldwide enterprise, so we’re inspired that DocuSign is retaining the momentum happening that entrance.

On the know-how entrance, the corporate launched CLM Necessities, a “answer centered on quicker time to worth and is constructed particularly for rising organizations to centralize and automate the creating, negotiating, and safe storage of their contracts.” Seems like DocuSign created a CLM mild model with a cheaper price level to draw new clients to its platform or to develop their utilization past eSignature. After all, the corporate has continued so as to add new options to its flagship eSignature merchandise, together with an up to date ID verification function that permits signers to confirm their id through monetary establishments like Financial institution of America, Chase, and Wells Fargo.

Its greatest public enterprise coup is a current enlargement of its partnership with Microsoft, which is able to add new DocuSign Settlement Cloud integrations and capabilities throughout Microsoft’s enterprise options. As well as, each firms pledged to spend extra money on one another’s merchandise to be used inside their very own organizations. As we famous earlier, different cloud-based doc administration firms supply integrations, with Adobe being the obvious instance, so the magnitude of the deal is considerably relative.

It will be most useful if the corporate broke down revenues by product section so we have now some colour round how briskly their three predominant product segments are rising.

For instance, how a lot income is being realized from the net notarization service they launched following the acquisition of Liveoak in 2020? Adobe just lately introduced a partnership with Notarize, a startup that’s raised $213 million in funding. We already find out about DocuSign’s success in eSignature, however we’d prefer to see some colour round how the opposite two product segments are figuring out when it comes to income progress.

Conclusion

DocuSign says it’s capturing for $5 billion in income, however doesn’t supply any form of timeline to attain that progress or whether or not it expects to be worthwhile by that time. We consider the corporate can leverage its main market place within the eSignature market to construct its CLM enterprise and show that it’s not simply one other pandemic surprise inventory with little resiliency when occasions get powerful. With reference as to whether or not we purchased shares following at the moment’s dip, that’s one thing Nanalyze Premium subscribers had been alerted to earlier at the moment.

Tech investing is extraordinarily dangerous. Decrease your danger with our inventory analysis, funding instruments, and portfolios, and discover out which tech shares it’s best to keep away from. Change into a Nanalyze Premium member and discover out at the moment!