I’m thrilled that so a lot of you joined us for final month’s first ever Learn With Crystal E book Membership! I acquired message after message from folks saying how a lot you loved the guide and love this concept — and that makes me so ecstatic!
If you happen to didn’t know in regards to the guide membership otherwise you want a refresher, listed below are particulars earlier than I share my assessment of September’s guide and announce October’s guide membership decide!

How the E book Membership Works
Right here’s the way it works:
1. I announce the guide membership decide for the month on the weblog and on social media. You should purchase the guide on-line, from an area guide retailer, get it from the library, or hearken to the audiobook. You select!
2. We learn via the guide that month. I’ll point out it right here and there on social media or on the weblog. I’ll not. It simply relies upon!
3. On the finish of the month, I put up a put up with my full assessment and ideas of the guide. I’ll invite you to share your ideas within the feedback on that weblog put up or within the put up I share on social media.
4. That’s it! We’ll repeat this each month with a brand new guide.
You may be a part of us each month or simply on the months that the guide appears attention-grabbing to you. No matter works for you — this can be a no obligation guide membership!

What I Considered September’s E book Membership Decide
September’s guide decide was Woman Tan’s Circle of Girls. And I’ve SOO many ideas on this guide. It made me pissed off. It made me grateful. It made me unhappy. However I additionally liked the tales of girls caring deeply for each other, at nice threat to themselves to take action generally.
Why It Made Me Annoyed
I knew that ladies have been oppressed and devalued in different cultures, however to examine the way it actually labored out within the day-to-day was so appalling! Like, I wished to shake a number of the guide characters and be like, “Simply cease it already! Deal with her with respect. She isn’t any much less price of respect than you might be!”
I additionally felt pissed off as a result of the medical care was so horrible for girls. The considered being recognized by a health care provider who would solely discuss to you thru a display and wouldn’t even discuss on to you however would have another person be a go-between!!
Additionally, I couldn’t consider how girls have been stored mainly chained to their homes and barely ever – if ever – noticed exterior the partitions of their home! That was surprising to me and exhausting to grasp.
As well as, I struggled with the elements that talked about how marriage mainly meant you have been utterly lower off from your loved ones and have been now, in essence, the property of your husband’s household.
Why It Made Me Unhappy
Okay, I had heard of foot-binding earlier than however I genuinely had by no means considered what the method was truly like or how it could truly be crippling to a lady. And so they did it simply to look “stunning” for his or her husbands — though he by no means would truly see their ft as a result of they at all times stored them in booties (I’m guessing as a result of they really regarded terrible!)
To think about the ache and discomfort this may put girls via each single second of each single day. It was so unhappy to me.
However not solely that, the saddest half to me was studying about how the moms have been those who would do the foot binding to their women and the way exhausting this may be for them due to the ache they have been placing their daughters via to mainly break the bones after which wrap the ft to make them actually tiny.
I researched on-line and right here’s extra on foot-binding (you can even discover photos however be ready to be aghast!):
Foot binding was a historic Chinese language customized of tightly wrapping younger women’ ft with material to interrupt bones and create small, extremely arched Lotus Ft. The apply lasted for almost a thousand years earlier than it was lastly stopped within the twentieth century. [1, 2, 3]
How the Course of Labored
- Age: The method normally began when a lady was between 4 and 6 years outdated. [1]
- Soaking: Family soaked the lady’s ft in heat water or natural mixtures to melt the pores and skin. [1, 2]
- Bending: They bent all of the toes besides the massive toe beneath the only of the foot. [1]
- Wrapping: They used lengthy material bandages to wrap the foot tightly, which broke the small bones and compelled the foot right into a excessive arch. [1, 2]
- Aim: The perfect goal measurement was about three inches lengthy, referred to as a “golden lotus” foot. You may be taught extra in regards to the mechanics and historical past of this tradition on Britannica. [1, 2]
Why It Made Me Grateful
I learn the guide pondering how grateful I’m to reside in a rustic and time interval and marriage the place I’ve a lot price, worth, dignity, and respect. I believe we will take these items as a right generally and learning completely different cultures and historic instances can provide us contemporary perspective on how a lot we’ve to be glad about.
I additionally thought there have been so many stunning elements of the guide the place different girls have been caring so deeply for each other, the place males would buck the norm to maintain girls and care about their wants, and the place girls would threat their lives for different girls.
What did you consider Woman Tan’s Circle of Girls? I’d love to listen to! Inform us within the feedback!

My IG Reside With Lisa See
Psst! Don’t miss my IG reside with the creator! It was unimaginable! Lisa See is a wealth of historic knowledge and her insights and perspective added such depth to this month’s guide membership!
Lisa has spent years of her life researching for her books and her ardour for her characters is totally contagious! The truth is, after we completed this reside, I instantly wished to go learn all 12 of her different books!
Just a few of the matters we coated:
-How the apply of foot-binding was truly seen as one thing that will actually elevate their daughter’s place and shield her in the long term.
-Why she spent 40 hours of analysis for one single sentence in her guide.
-What it was wish to attempt to write a guide in the course of a pandemic when so many choices for analysis weren’t obtainable.
-The extent of isolation girls felt in China throughout this time interval however how they’d construct relationships with girls and benefit from a life lived in an enclosed compound.
-Easy methods to extra deeply recognize our personal circles of girls.
Watch the complete IG reside interview right here. I’ve a sense you’ll want to learn all of Lisa’s books after watching it.

October’s E book Membership Decide
I’m excited to announce this month’s guide membership decide is Beneath a Scarlet Sky. This guide is one I’ve had on my shelf for years, has been extremely really helpful to me over and over, and one I’ve deliberate to learn so many instances.
Right here’s the outline from Amazon:
Primarily based on the true story of a forgotten hero, the USA Immediately and #1 Amazon Charts bestseller Beneath a Scarlet Sky is the triumphant, epic story of 1 younger man’s unimaginable braveness and resilience throughout one in every of historical past’s darkest hours.
Pino Lella desires nothing to do with the struggle or the Nazis. He’s a traditional Italian teenager—obsessive about music, meals, and women—however his days of innocence are numbered. When his household house in Milan is destroyed by Allied bombs, Pino joins an underground railroad serving to Jews escape over the Alps, and falls for Anna, a phenomenal widow six years his senior.
In an try to guard him, Pino’s dad and mom pressure him to enlist as a German soldier—a transfer they assume will maintain him out of fight. However after Pino is injured, he’s recruited on the tender age of eighteen to turn into the non-public driver for Adolf Hitler’s left hand in Italy, Basic Hans Leyers, one of many Third Reich’s most mysterious and highly effective commanders.
Now, with the chance to spy for the Allies contained in the German Excessive Command, Pino endures the horrors of the struggle and the Nazi occupation by combating in secret, his braveness bolstered by his love for Anna and for the life he goals they are going to at some point share.
Followers of All of the Mild We Can’t See, The Nightingale, and Unbroken will take pleasure in this riveting saga of historical past, suspense, and love.

I figured I might selfishly decide it for guide membership this month so I’d truly get it learn! Get a replica of Beneath a Scarlet Sky right here — or verify your native library to get a replica.
Easy methods to Learn Beneath a Scarlet Sky for Free
In case you are somebody who likes to learn ebooks, you will get the Kindle model of Beneath a Scarlet Sky utterly FREE proper now via Kindle Limitless!! (They’re providing a free 3-month subscription to Prime Members and it’s FREE on Kindle Limitless!)
Or, you will get the audiobook of Beneath a Scarlet Sky without spending a dime via Amazon Music (they’re at the moment providing 3-4 months free and also you get a free audiobook every month!)

Any questions? Ask away within the feedback! Additionally, in case you have solutions for future guide membership books, let me know! I can be compiling an inventory!
Word: I’ll do my finest to choose books which are clear (no bed room scenes) and don’t have loads of cursing in them. Nonetheless, since I received’t have learn the guide earlier than I decide it, I’m not endorsing a guide simply by selecting it. However I’ll do my finest to analysis it to strive to verify it’s not more than a PG or PG-13 kind guide.
