Lessons Learned from SEO Tests that Didn’t “Win” – Whiteboard Friday

We love to speak about profitable search engine marketing checks, like these great cases the place you run an A/B take a look at and also you see constructive affect. In at present’s episode, although, Will goes to debate the dropping checks: these with damaging outcomes — or no outcomes — the place you could not show an affect. 

These take a look at outcomes are, in reality, the place you possibly can seemingly discover probably the most precious insights.

Click on on the whiteboard picture above to open a excessive decision model in a brand new tab!

Video Transcription

Hello, Moz followers. My title is Will Critchlow. I am the founder and CEO at SearchPilot. We run tons of search engine marketing checks, and if you happen to’ve ever seen me converse on considered one of these earlier than or on an even bigger stage, you’ve got most likely heard me speak about lots of profitable checks, these good conditions the place you run an A/B take a look at and also you get an uplift and also you get to have a good time. At present, we’ll be speaking about dropping checks. So these could be the damaging ones or the ineffective modifications, those the place you simply could not show an affect in both course.

So that is basically that scenario the place you discover an perception. It is likely to be key phrase analysis. It is likely to be from technical auditing of the location, no matter it is likely to be. You have got a principle. You have got a speculation or one thing that’s going to learn your web site. You implement the change because of this, and also you fall flat in your face. You fail spectacularly, and your take a look at end result information seems a bit bit like this.

Now, that is truly fairly an exaggerated case. A whole lot of the failures that we see are -2%, -3%, or simply flat line, and people -2% and -3% kind ones could be actually onerous to select up with out scientifically managed testing, which is what we focus lots of our time on, on actually large web sites. They will actually add up. In case you are constantly rolling out these little damaging modifications by means of the course of the 12 months, it could actually be a drag in your search engine marketing program as an entire. However they will get misplaced. You roll out that change, and it could get misplaced within the noise, the seasonality, different sitewide modifications, Google algorithm updates, issues your rivals rise up to. That is what we’re attempting to identify and keep away from.

What are you able to be taught? 

So what can we be taught from dropping checks, and when can they profit us as a enterprise? Nicely, one of many, maybe, counterintuitive advantages is the drop in effort that you just is likely to be asking of your engineering group. In case you have all these concepts and beforehand you are asking your group to construct all of them, however if you happen to run checks and you discover that a few of your concepts have been damaging, a few of them have been ineffective and weren’t going to learn you, you are now solely asking your product and engineering group to keep up those that end up to have a constructive search engine marketing affect. We have seen that be as much as an 80% drop in search engine marketing tickets for engineering. In order that’s one enterprise case proper there.

However, in fact, typically your checks appear to be this, and so truly the enterprise case is about avoiding these damaging impacts in your web site. 

Tactical examples

So I’ve acquired a few tactical examples that I believed could be good to run by means of that is likely to be helpful in your conditions as nicely.

The primary one is a case of eradicating search engine marketing textual content. So we have seen many circumstances the place suppose, say, a class web page on an e-commerce web site, for instance. You’ve got acquired a bunch of product listings, after which someplace down on the backside of the web page, there is a little bit of copy. Perhaps it is in a div, seo_text. Perhaps it is a actually small font, grey, not precisely white on a white background, however clearly not designed for human eyes. Now we have run some experiments the place we had conditions like that, with fairly poor-quality textual content on class pages. We examined eradicating it and really noticed a statistically vital drop in natural visibility, which is a disgrace, as a result of we all know that this is not high-quality textual content, we all know it isn’t the place Google needs us to be, and but eradicating it was a nasty concept.

One of many issues we are able to be taught from that’s say, firstly, do not throw the newborn out with the bathwater. You possibly can’t simply knee-jerk react to Google’s PR and all these sorts of issues and say, “Nicely, greatest practices say this. Let’s simply do it straightaway.” You possibly can’t do this with out testing since you is likely to be hurting your web site. Nevertheless it does level to a course of potential future enchancment, as a result of if having horrible textual content is best than no textual content, having good textual content is likely to be even higher. So one of many issues that you just profit from with a dropping take a look at is you get to be taught, and so that you get to level the course to some insights that is likely to be constructive for you sooner or later.

The opposite instance I’ve acquired for you right here, you is likely to be questioning what on earth that is, and artwork will not be my sturdy level. That is an Easter egg. Belief me, that is an Easter egg. We noticed an instance of an internet site, that operated throughout the entire of Europe, a number of completely different nation/territory web sites, testing including seasonal presents. So on this case, it was about Easter journey, Easter breaks, Easter flights, these sorts of issues. The key phrase analysis had urged that there was demand for this, that the viewers is looking out in this sort of manner, and but, including these presents to the web page was damaging, and that was very stunning. What it turned out was occurring right here was that it was diluting the standard of that web page for the issues that have been the bread and butter of these touchdown pages. So, sure, it was rating higher for some Easter travel-type associated searches, but it surely was doing worse for the majority of visitors of simply journeys to metropolis title or no matter it is likely to be, and the web affect was damaging. That is the form of factor you possibly can solely choose up by looking out.

So I hope you have loved this little journey into dropping search engine marketing checks and what we are able to be taught from them. My title is Will Critchlow. I am at SearchPilot. Yow will discover me on Twitter, @willcritchlow. Look ahead to chatting to you quickly. Take care.

Video transcription by Speechpad.com