Is Cisco’s deal to buy Splunk a good idea? Wall Street isn’t sure.

Regardless of being reported on final 12 months, Cisco Programs (NASDAQ:CSCO) shocked Wall Road this week when it stated it meant to amass cybersecurity agency Splunk (NASDAQ:SPLK) for $28B.

Whereas some buyers have considered the deal to spice up the corporate’s annual recurring income and enhance its monetary profile as a constructive, the collective response on Wall Road has been akin to the shrug emoji.

Needham analyst Alex Henderson, who has a maintain score on Cisco (CSCO), stated the deal won’t remedy Cisco’s issues, due partially to the corporate’s “poor” observe document of realizing synergies with previous acquisitions.

“Cisco’s Safety enterprise, regardless of quite a few acquisitions, remains to be primarily not Cloud-Native or Micro-Companies-based, and Cisco is shedding share in Safety,” Henderson wrote in an investor notice, including that he expects Splunk’s progress decelerate over the following a number of years.

“We see the deal as a merger of two legacy gamers in a class the place new competitors is rising from robust platform Safety names akin to CrowdStrike’s (CRWD) LogScale and Palo Alto (PANW), that are instantly concentrating on the legacy [security information and event management] market,” he added.

Jefferies analyst George Notter was a bit extra constructive on the deal, highlighting the deal with knowledge extraction and evaluation, Splunk’s specialty. Nonetheless, the deal may also require some integration Notter stated, which Cisco has had a combined historical past with.

The deal will lead to combining of Cisco’s Prolonged Detection & Response platform and VAS Safe Perception instruments with Splunk’s Safety Data & Occasion Administration instruments, which Notter famous the corporate didn’t present a timetable for.

Notter additionally identified that whereas Cisco has greater than 80,000 channel companions all over the world, Splunk is essentially based mostly within the U.S. (two-thirds of income are home) and it has an “immature” gross sales channel technique.

“Nonetheless, the strategic nature of the deal, the flexibility to speed up Cisco’s progress fee, and the flexibility to additional the transition to recurring income fashions make this deal worthwhile, in our view,” Notter wrote in a notice.

Notter has a purchase score and $59.50 value goal on Cisco shares.

KeyBanc Capital Markets analyst Thomas Blakey, who has a sector-weight score on Cisco (CSCO), stated the deal is a constructive for Cisco (CSCO).

“We view this transaction positively for Cisco because it leverages the corporate’s present place … and provides to its answer units which might be benefiting from secular tendencies in safety, AI, and observability.

Blakey added that the deal will enable each firms to allow new and present prospects to get extra worth from throughout the IT stack.

And whereas the execution threat for the merger is “comparatively excessive” given the dimensions and competitiveness of the markets the place Cisco (CSCO) and Splunk (SPLK) intersect, in addition to integration threat, Blakey stated there are “[long-term] deserves” for the deal, on condition that he expects the synergies are extra focused in the direction of rising income and fewer about reducing bills.